Major League Baseball’s Historical Quest to Entice Middle- and Upper-Class Fans to the Park

This piece is a response to our name for submissions, Histories of Sport. For our submission tips, click on here.

In June, I attended Main League Baseball’s (MLB) London Collection—one in all MLB’s many makes an attempt to increase its fanbase. Baseball (or not less than its fashionable, American model) has by no means been notably well-liked in the UK, regardless of quite a few efforts by American businesspeople over the past practically 150 years to make it so.^[1] On condition that, I anticipated a international feeling at London Stadium for the video games. Constructed for the 2012 Olympics and now the house of West Ham United Soccer Membership, the stadium was clearly not designed for baseball, and listening to “God Save the King” sung earlier than a baseball recreation was jarring. Nevertheless, arriving on the venue was an oddly acquainted expertise.

An American agency accountable designing for a lot of MLB ballparks, Populous, collectively designed the power with an English agency. The 20-minute stroll from the closest tube cease to London Stadium took me by way of high-rise apartment buildings with fashionable bars, eating places, and high-end purchasing at road stage, not dissimilar from the areas surrounding major-league ballparks in Washington, D.C., Chicago, suburban Atlanta, and St. Louis. On reflection, I shouldn’t have been shocked by this familiarity. Other than the push for Sunday baseball between the 1910s and the early Nineteen Thirties and the establishment of night time video games within the Nineteen Thirties and Forties, each main try and carry extra followers to MLB ballparks has been primarily geared at attracting extra middle- and upper-class individuals.

MLB’s concentrate on wealthier followers stands in stark distinction to rhetoric concerning the ballpark that had lengthy known as it a website of egalitarian intermixing. In 1912, for instance, a author for Baseball Journal argued that the fan “is the consultant American establishment. His ranks are stuffed from each class of society, by each one of many many nationalities which mix to make the American nation.”^[2] That very same yr, journalist Hugh Fullerton wrote that “in stand and bleachers all are equal throughout a tough recreation.”^[3] Equally, in 1935 Meyer Berger claimed within the New York Instances that “on the top of his frenzy, the rooter is aware of no class distinction.”^[4] In 1988, writer Peter Golenbock argued, “black, white, Christian, Jew, Hindu, Moslem, homosexual or straight, pro-abortion, pro-life, the disparate curiosity teams agree on little besides for his or her love of the Nationwide Pastime. Go to a ball recreation. In Fenway Park Harvard Professors sit and discuss the identical language with the followers with blue collars.”^[5]

Whereas the main focus of this piece is entry to MLB video games throughout socioeconomic class, it’s vital to notice that race and, specifically, whiteness, has lengthy been a central organizing factor of baseball in america.[6] A few of my different scholarship focuses on racial segregation within the stands at MLB ballparks, the way wherein MLB parks had been designed to reply to white Individuals’ feelings about city area, and the numerous ways in which Black Individuals had been marginalized at MLB ballparks.[7]

At first of the 20th century, St. Louis was the southern- and westernmost metropolis with an MLB staff and all MLB video games had been performed throughout the day. Though most midwestern cities permitted MLB groups to play video games on Sundays, at half of MLB amenities, Sunday video games had been unlawful.^[8] In an period when most working-class jobs had been six-days-a-week commitments, lots of these employees had been unable to attend video games commonly. Between the 1910s and the Nineteen Thirties, staff homeowners and baseball followers efficiently pushed legislators to legalize Sunday baseball, leading to elevated attendance, notably amongst working-class followers.^[9]

{A photograph} of the outside of the unique Yankee Stadium, c. 1925. Courtesy Library of Congress.

Elevated attendance, nevertheless, made it extra doubtless that middle- and upper-class followers, whose comparably versatile work schedule allowed them to attend extra commonly, may nicely encounter working-class followers. Group homeowners fearful such encounters would push wealthier followers away. Yankee Stadium, which opened in 1923, partially rectified the problem with its then-unique three-tiered construction.^[10] The bodily tiers of the stadium got here with in another way priced tickets, that means that rich Yankees followers might pay extra in the event that they needed to observe Babe Ruth with out sitting subsequent to working-class followers. Lots of Yankee Stadium’s improvements would come to be integrated in later parks.

Throughout MLB, all video games had been performed in daylight till 1935, when Cincinnati Reds president Larry MacPhail satisfied the opposite Nationwide League homeowners to permit his staff to host the primary seven night time video games in MLB historical past. The Reds had been, on the time, one in all MLB’s worst groups they usually had been in one in all its smallest cities—in different phrases, that they had fewer potential followers to start with and people followers had little cause to observe them. Evening video games, performed completely on weekdays, allowed many extra followers to attend.^[11] In 1935, the Reds drew roughly as many followers from their seven night time video games as they drew from all different weekday video games that season mixed—a couple of third of their complete attendance that season.^[12] Though World Struggle II restrictions hindered the unfold of night time baseball, by 1948 fifteen of sixteen MLB groups had been taking part in night time video games of their house ballparks, permitting followers who labored throughout the day to attend commonly.

As night time video games elevated, some MLB groups—notably the Philadelphia A’s and the New York Yankees—created non-public golf equipment for his or her season and box-seat ticket holders, who, given the price of these tickets, had been the followers more than likely to be rich. One journalist described the Stadium Membership at Yankee Stadium, which opened in 1946, as “two swank taverns below the stands the place thirsty holders of season tickets [could]quaff a stray beaker secure from the vulgar gaze of the hoi-polloi” and one other mentioned it was the place “the elite meet to eat.”^[13] As a result of night time video games meant extra individuals might attend, staff homeowners offered their wealthiest followers with new areas additional faraway from the lots. Because the success of the Stadium Membership quickly grew to become evident, different MLB groups opened their very own variations.

In fact, unique areas for the wealthiest followers had no impression on postwar suburbanization. As extra middle- and upper-class followers left city areas for the suburbs and the sunbelt south, MLB made positive to cater to them by relocating franchises to the suburbs or the sunbelt south and including growth franchises in new elements of the nation. The Fifties, Sixties, and Nineteen Seventies noticed MLB improve from sixteen groups to twenty-six and featured a wave of latest, car- and suburban-accessible stadiums with much more unique areas than their predecessors. Most of these amenities had been constructed with municipal funding—a rarity earlier than 1950 however primarily the rule for each stadium constructed since then—and their price was usually disproportionately borne by poorer, city residents, whereas the stadiums had been designed with suburbanites in thoughts.

Maybe probably the most modern of the brand new stadiums was the Harris County Domed Stadium, higher often called the Astrodome after its main tenant, the Houston Astros. The Astrodome opened in 1965 and was paid for by municipal bonds that price far, excess of the county acquired in hire on the power. The place Yankee Stadium’s three tiers had as soon as been novel, the Astrodome had seven. It was functionally inaccessible through mass transportation, largely reachable solely by non-public vehicle and subsequently completely fitted to metropolitan Houston’s rising middle- and upper-class suburban inhabitants. Other than absolutely the most cost-effective seats within the ballpark, each one had cushioned backs and bottoms (the “low cost” seats solely had cushioned bottoms) and had been supposed to rival “the world’s most interesting theatres.”^[14] In describing the advantages of a local weather managed indoor baseball stadium, one Astros government mentioned that “ladies will take a distinct view of sports activities occasions…. They’ll have their hair accomplished, put on a brand new costume, and are available to a ball recreation as simple and as snug as going to the opera.”^[15] One commentator famous that “the Astrodome introduced opera to sports activities, the sorts of crowds you noticed there, the costume, the style, the style, the model.”^[16]

The Astrodome within the foreground, displaying its surrounding parking heaps and vehicle accessibility. Photograph by Carol M. Highsmith. Courtesy Carol M. Highsmith Archive, Library of Congress, Prints and Images Division. By way of Library of Congress.

The clearest indicators that the ballpark was aiming to draw an elite viewers, nevertheless, had been its pioneering skyboxes situated on the high of the dome. The fifty-three skyboxes had a capability of both twenty-four, thirty, or fifty-four followers and will solely be reached by non-public elevators.^[17] All had been leased on five-year phrases at a price of between $15,000 and $34,000 yearly.^[18] Skybox facilities included a inventory ticker, ice maker, gold phone, silver espresso urn, and personal rest room.^[19] As a Sports activities Illustrated reporter famous, every field was “adorned in a riot of astounding kinds from western to Oriental to heaven-knows-what” and named after its design theme.^[20] A few of these names included Imperial Orient, Pagoda Den, Panjim Emerald, Egyptian Autumn, Outdated South, Southern Plantation, Outdated Mexico, The Aztec, Hispania, Spanish Woman, Laverne Aloha, and Tahitian Vacation.^[21] Designed to most attraction to the wealthiest followers, the Astrodome was the latest and fanciest stadium, the one different MLB homeowners quickly copied and the inspiration for the proliferation of luxurious suites throughout skilled sports activities.

By the Eighties, the Astrodome’s modernist model and suburban location fell out of favor with baseball followers, staff homeowners, and designers; the subsequent wave of ballpark design was postmodern and, within the phrases of a number of observers, “urbanoid.”^[22] One of many earliest and most influential of those ballparks was Baltimore’s Oriole Park at Camden Yards, designed by the agency that will later be often called Populous, which opened in 1992. It was funded by a collection of specifically created state lottery video games that, as one elected official famous “[prey]  upon the poorest members of society.”[23] In different phrases, the majority of the development prices had been borne by lower-income Marylanders. Related funding schemes grew to become widespread throughout MLB.

{A photograph} of Camden Yards displaying downtown Baltimore and Inside Harbor—the situation of Harborplace—within the distance. Photograph by Carol M. Highsmith. Courtesy Carol M. Highsmith’s America, Library of Congress, Prints and Images Division. By way of Library of Congress.

Furthermore, Camden Yards was not removed from Harborplace, town’s renovated harbor space that, within the Eighties, had been remodeled with retailers and museums catering to a primarily middle- and upper-class, suburban viewers. Like its neighbor, regardless of being within the metropolis, Camden Yards was designed to attraction to rich suburbanites greater than to working-class urbanites. Within the phrases of geographer Darrel Crilley, areas like Harborplace and Camden Yards had been “programmed to filter the social heterogeneity of the city crowd, substituting instead a flawless cloth of white center class work, play and consumption.”^[24] Not solely did poor Marylanders contribute many of the building prices, however the facility was designed to marginalize them. Within the many years since Camden Yards opened, all however a handful of MLB groups have moved into new parks that, like Camden Yards, are designed to extract as a lot cash as potential from the wealthiest of followers moderately than to develop curiosity in baseball amongst poorer Individuals.

Given the trajectory of MLB stadium design, the London Collection suits squarely in MLB’s sample of making an attempt to extend its fanbase among the many middle- and upper-classes, pricing working-class followers out of ballparks. Moreover, London Stadium and its environs mirror the construction of many American venues, with surrounding residences and companies that cater to middle- and upper-class followers. As capitalists, MLB and baseball franchise homeowners are firstly curious about growing income, they usually see extracting extra money from their wealthiest followers as one of the simplest ways to try this, moderately than increasing their fanbase as broad as they will.

Seth S. Tannenbaum is an assistant professor of sport research at Manhattanville College. He earned a Ph.D. in American Historical past at Temple College and a B.A. in Historical past at Vassar Faculty. His educating and analysis concentrate on utilizing sport to unpack and perceive the world round us. His manuscript, “Greater than a Ballpark: The Baseball Fan Expertise as a Window into American Society,” examines Individuals’ altering understandings of city areas, inclusion, and the physique politic. It analyzes how, amid important modifications in cities and in leisure consumption patterns, staff homeowners formed and reshaped the fan expertise to strengthen the social hierarchies that existed outdoors the ballpark. His scholarship has been revealed in The Journal of Sport Historical past, The Journal of African American Historical past, and 9: A Journal of Baseball Historical past & Tradition, amongst quite a lot of different venues. Alongside together with his Manhattanville Sport Research colleagues, Dr. Tannenbaum is a co­–undertaking director for a Nationwide Endowment for the Humanities grant analyzing the intersection of Latinx research and sport research.

^[1] Thomas W. Zeiler, Ambassadors in Pinstripes: The Spalding World Baseball Tour and the Delivery of the American Empire (2006).

^[2] William A. Phelon, “The Nice American Fan: A Nationwide Establishment,” Baseball Journal, June 1912, p. 1.

[3] Hugh S. Fullerton, “Followers: Motto: Could the Finest Group Win; However Ours Is the Finest,” American Journal, 74 (Aug. 1912), 465–66.

^[4] Meyer Berger, “Within the Ball Park Each Man’s a King,” New York Instances, April 14, 1935.

^[5] Peter Golenbock, “Preface,” in The Better of Spitball, ed. Mike Shannon (1988), 5–6.

[6] Ryan A. Swanson, When Baseball Went White: Reconstruction, Reconciliation, and Desires of a Nationwide Pastime (2014).

[7] Seth S. Tannenbaum, “The Desegregation of Sportsman’s Park in St. Louis: Black Baseball Followers’ Use of the Nationwide Pastime to Struggle White Supremacy,” Journal of African American Historical past, 106 (Spring 2021), 220–48; Seth S. Tannenbaum, “How Main League Baseball Parks Reveal the White Center-Class’s Views on Cities,” Journal of Sport Historical past, 50 (Spring 2023), 32–47; “Seth Tannenbaum on the Historic Marginalization of Black Followers at Main League Baseball Video games,” June 11, 2024 in BSSH Sport in Historical past Podcast, produced by Geoff Levett, podcast, MP3 audio, https://soundcloud.com/bssh-london/seth-tannenbaum-on-the-historical-marginalization-of-black-fans-at-major-league-baseball-games.

^[8] Steven A. Riess, Touching Base: Skilled Baseball and American Tradition within the Progressive Period  (1999), 134–55.

^[9] Ibid., 52.

^[10] Roi L. Morin, “Stadia—Half II: The Yankee Stadium, New York Osborn Engineering Co., Architects and Engineers,” American Architect and the Architectural Assessment, Nov. 7, 1923, pp. 412–16.

^[11] Larry MacPhail, “The Triumph of the Arc Lights,” Baseball Journal, Sept. 1936, p. 445.

^[12] “Large League Baseball,” Fortune, Aug. 1937, p. 116.

^[13] Arthur Daley, “Extra Stars, Extra Followers, Extra All the pieces: Superlatives Mark the Publish-Struggle Baseball Season Which Opens on Tuesday with Tumult and Shouting,” New York Instances, April 14, 1946; Homosexual Talese, “There Are Followers—And Yankee Followers,” New York Instances, June 19, 1958.

^[14] The Houston Sports activities Affiliation, Inc., Contained in the Astrodome: The Eighth Marvel of the World! (1965), 41.

^[15] Dave Bruce, “Rain or Shine Stadium,” Texas Parade, n.d., folder 18: Stadiums—Astrodome, field 46, collection III: Topic Information, 1876–1998, American League Papers (A. Barlett Giamatti Analysis Middle, Nationwide Baseball Corridor of Fame and Museum, Cooperstown, N.Y.).

^[16] Geoff Winningham, dir., The Pleasures of This Stately Dome: A Celebration of the tenth Anniversary of the Astrodome, prod. Geoff Winningham (1976).

^[17] Astrodome tri-fold pamphlet, folder 18: Stadiums—Astrodome, field 46, collection III: Topic Information, 1876–1998, American League Papers.

^[18] “In Texas, The place All the pieces Is Large, Houston Stadium Is the Best,” New York Instances, Dec. 6, 1964.

^[19] “The Enterprise of Baseball,” Newsweek, April 26, 1965, p. 66.

^[20] Liz Smith, “Giltfinger’s Golden Dome,” Sports activities Illustrated, April 12, 1965, p. 56.

^[21] Houston Sports activities Affiliation, Contained in the Astrodome, 34.

^[22] John Hannigan, Fantasy Metropolis: Pleasure and Revenue within the Postmodern Metropolis (1998), 6.

[23] Roz Hamlett, “Will Stadium Be Constructed on the Backs of the Poor?” Baltimore Afro-American, March 14, 1987.

^[24] Darrell Crilley, “Megastructures and City Change: Aesthetics, Ideology and Design,” in The Stressed City Panorama, ed. Paul L. Knox (1993), 154.